DIY vs. Professional Roof Replacement – Pros and Cons

There’s no denying the fact that with proper knowledge and skills anyone can DIY whatever they want, including even roof replacement. 

However, the popular option is hiring a professional roofing company to get the job done, as they’re not only skilled and experienced at the job but can do so perfectly without leaving any room for errors. And this might not be the case when you try to go the DIY route. 

Moreover, when you do DIY roof replacement, it may result in potentially serious injuries and the roof you just replaced might not even last as long as you expected. 

If you’re considering DIY roof replacement, there are several factors you need to consider. Undoubtedly, it will save you some money, but it’s worth going through the pros and cons of DIY vs. professional roof replacement to make an informed choice. 

DIY Roof Replacement

First thing first, do deep research into how to go about roof replacement, removing the old roof, and the tools and roofing materials you need. 

Apart from knowing the materials you need, it’s also important to calculate how much materials you need. 

Removing the roof is also a skill-based task you need to understand intricately before executing. 

If you think all this is too much for you, trust Stormtrooper Roofing to get the job done well. Moreover, our roof replacement projects come with a warranty, ensuring complete peace of mind.

DIY Roof Replacement – Pros 

Cost Savings

One of the obvious reasons why homeowners contemplate going for DIY roof replacement is the cost savings. It eliminates the labor expenditures from the roof replacement project. 

Going the DIY route also allows total control over material selection in terms of market research. This enables you to browse through the market and select the most cost-effective option as per your budget. 


Going the DIY route for roof replacement allows you to personalize the roof as per your taste and preference. From the roof material you choose to design and the style you employ, everything is in your control. 

DIY roof replacement ensures the final result is exactly as you envisioned without compromising on any aesthetic or functional elements you wished for in your roof. 

Learning Experience

It goes without saying that when you go for DIY roof replacement, it’s a learning experience that upgrades your skills and improves your cognitive abilities. It’s a great opportunity for personal growth, discovery, and learning. The hands-on experience you get also helps with other tasks related to home improvement and maintenance. 

DIY Roof Replacement – Cons

While having gone through the pros of DIY roof replacement, let us briefly go through the cons as well to give you a clear picture. 

Safety Risks

Needless to say, there’s a good chance of suffering from injuries during the project, including a fatal fall from the roof. Handling various tools and materials inappropriately can also lead to injuries and increase the chance of accidents. Moreover, without proper precautions in place, you may also end up putting others at risk as well. 

Lack of Expertise

Roof replacement needs experience and skills, and DIYers may not have the expertise to identify if they come across other structural issues during the project, like problems with underlays, damages, leakages, rotting, etc. 

Professional roofers have the training, experience, and knowledge necessary to assess and inspect the roof’s condition and take care of other structural aspects, if necessary, to provide a comprehensive and reliable roof replacement job. 

Limited Warranty Coverage 

Most manufacturers’ warranties are only applicable if it’s professionally installed. Going the DIY route voids the materials manufacturer’s warranty. At Stormtrooper Roofing, our roof replacement projects and workmanship are backed by warranties you can rely on!

Limited Insurance Coverage 

In many cases, the homeowner’s insurance policies do not cover any accidents or damages caused during DIY roof replacement. So, if anything happens that needs expensive repairs or overhaul – it goes out of your pocket. 

Professional roofers have insurance coverage, ensuring you’re not liable to pay for any unwanted accidents that may occur during the roof replacement. 

Pros & Cons of Professional Roof Replacement 

If you’re considering roof replacement, it might be a good idea to go through the pros of professional roof replacement as well before you make the final decision. 

Pros –

  • Experience & Knowledge 
  • Licensed, Insured, and Bonded Roofing Company
  • Professional Roofers – Qualified & Trained!
  • Ensures Long-Term Savings (No need to spend on repairs frequently)
  • Timely Job
  • Warranty Backed Job

Cons –

  • Relatively more expensive than the DIY Roof Replacement due to additional labor costs.
  • May have to wait for a while if the contractor is tied up with other jobs. 

Final Takeaway 

If you’ve considerable experience with the handy work and feel confident about the DIY roof replacement, there’s no harm in going for it. 

However, professional roof replacement is always preferred because it’s your home we’re talking about here, and you don’t want to put yourself and others at risk during the project due to a lack of expertise or handling skills. 

While it may cost a bit more, professional roof replacement is a money-saver in the long term as it ensures quality work done under professional supervision using high-quality roofing materials. It offers value for money when you look at the bigger picture, which is also why it’s the most commonly preferred route for roof replacement. 

If you’re looking to go for roof replacement too and are worried about the high cost involved or have unanswered queries or doubts, or if you need more clarity, contact Stormtrooper Roofing today! 

We will gladly help you get all the answers you need and provide a free, no-obligation consultation and quote!

More posts

montgomery county

Bucks county

Northampton county county

Lehigh county